2 Comments

Rangers gonna range, right Talker?

Expand full comment

That's one more reason the books were so far superior to the films. Aragorn was written as a reluctant hero (or at least a reluctant Heir of Isildur) in the filmed Fellowship of the Ring, whereas in the books Aragorn, once told his true heritage by Elrond, accepted it willingly -- not eagerly but willingly -- and spent decades doing his plain duty as he saw it: "...it seemed fit that Isildur's heir should labor to repair Isildur's fault...."

Similarly Faramir took up the mantle of leadership of the Rangers of Ithilien not for glory nor as a birthright, but out of a debt of duty he owed Gondor. I _hated*_ the twisting of Tolkien's line referring to "a mighty gift" in The Two Towers.

*Hate. _Haaaaaaaate._ DEEEEEEEP HATRED.

Expand full comment